Why roofing material should not be fastened with self-tapping screws: debunking the myth

click fraud protection

It is strange in the age of developing technologies to see how anyone uses nails at all. And what is it for if they have long been invented self-tapping screws - efficient and reliable fasteners. Nevertheless, it is difficult to convince roofers that self-tapping screws are better than nails. Let's see why this is so and why such a choice should be respected.

Read in the article

  • 1 Selection of experienced roofers
  • 2 What are rasp and screw nails and how do they work
  • 3 Self-tapping screws against nails: which is better?

Selection of experienced roofers

Interesting fact: roofers with extensive experience prefer to fix the roofing material not just with nails, but with black nails. Why not stainless steel, because, it would seem, it is much better than ferrous metal, which is prone to corrosion? And the point is just corrosion - after all, when a black nail, even if a little overgrown with rust, its adhesion to the board increases significantly. So the answer to the question is very simple. But more modern craftsmen use brushed nails for the roof.

What are rasp and screw nails and how do they work

For lathing construction, brushed nails are an excellent choice. And the strength properties of this fastener are superior to those of self-tapping screws.

Why roofing material should not be fastened with self-tapping screws
PHOTO: vld.intt.ru
A ruffled nail has transverse notches, which, when hammered, dig into the wood and fix the fasteners almost tightly. Each notch works as a stop

Only screw nails can argue with this. They also have notches, but they look like a drill. So when you drive a nail like this, it turns and screws into the wood.

Screw nails are used when it is necessary to obtain a particularly strong structure that will be subjected to mechanical stress.
PHOTO: pole1.ru
Screw nails are used when it is necessary to obtain a particularly strong structure that will be subjected to mechanical stress.

Self-tapping screws against nails: which is better?

On the one hand, self-tapping screws have a lot of advantages. Let's start with the obvious. When the wind is strong outside roofing material vibrates so that the nails slowly leave their nests if they do not have an additional notch for the hitch. But the self-tapping screw sits tightly in the crate, and so tightly that it would rather crush the roofing material than pop out by itself.

In general, damage occurs in both options, but the self-tapping screw will hold out for a longer time.PHOTO: uraremont.ru
In general, damage occurs in both options, but the self-tapping screw will hold out for a longer time.

When using a self-tapping screw, you can manually very finely adjust the degree of pressing of the material to the batten. This is very helpful when working with complex roof geometries. If the wood has dried up over time, the self-tapping screw can be tightened, this is also not bad.

But in this situation, there is not much sense in adding nails, you can still accidentally hit the roof and damage it. Usually, such fasteners are folded from the inside after the wood has dried, in order to tighten the material and secure the roof more reliably.

But we must admit that in terms of the rate of corrosion damage, self-tapping screws are inferior to nails. Even anodizing does not give an impressive result. And, of course, the self-tapping screw cannot be bent, it will simply break with such an effort.

In fact, the nail shows itself well, and its cap stays in place longer.PHOTO: avatars.mds.yandex.net
In fact, the nail shows itself well, and its cap stays in place longer.

If we talk about the price, then nails are cheaper, and several times. And finally, they differ from self-tapping screws in flexibility, that is, they bend with natural displacement, and do not break and do not lose their heads, like self-tapping screws.

What else can be compared? The very process of working with nails is more difficult: you missed - hit on your fingers or on metal.

The fingers will heal over time, but rust will soon appear in the place of the " wound" of the metalPHOTO: img11.postila.ru
The fingers will heal over time, but rust will soon appear in the place of the "wound" of the metal

What conclusion can be drawn from all this? First of all, you should respect the choice of roofers, because they make it consciously and this choice has strong arguments. If you decide to fix the roofing material yourself, then calculate your budget, estimate, which is more profitable for you, and, if possible, buy galvanized brushed nails, they are not let you down.

And in order for you to have a clear idea of ​​where and what fasteners are best used - this small video review:

What kind of fasteners do you prefer? Share your experience in the comments!

Discuss0

An ordinary village hut. Cluttered with all sorts of nonsense. The main thing is beautiful to describe. Generally, …

There used to be normal rules and terms of boiler maintenance - once a year, ...

I would live on Rublevka for a while, in a mansion. You can get a job as a gardener or ...

And you don’t think that the meters are put on the street because they are banal to those installed in the house ...

I have been using a sink made of artificial stone for 3 years, no problems.

Sheer nonsense! I have been using a stone sink for over 10 years. Every evening just a sponge with ...

You haven't bought the stove yet, will you? Write the result later. Cities are becoming dear to ...

I wonder who stole the picture "our team" from whom... Gosterm website. rf or monsieur Oshamya ...

In the USSR, it was the metering devices that were installed by the power grid for free, the tenant at his own expense ...

What are the standards for calculating a one-time inspection of gas appliances in an apartment and ...

Install a duplicate meter in the house and check the readings - in case of a large discrepancy ...

The SPETSAVIA company in Yaroslavl. Now it is the AMT group of companies. In Yekaterinburg, only about ...

The delirium of a man who, apart from the washstand, has never used anything in his life.

I love this actress for her talent and beauty.

Yes, these bastards generally got sick, bought a new gas stove for a private house, ready with ...

A bathhouse on the site must be required. Living outside the city sometimes it is necessary to sow ...

Metal tiles have been very expensive lately. Recently I ordered work on the lane ...

Very cozy, warm apartment. A talented person is talented in everything.